Hotels in Edgartown MA -- Refreshingly Honest Hotel Reviews

The Charlotte Inn

AVERAGE RATING

5.0

4+ reviews

Yahoo! Travel

5

2+ reviews

maid service, restaurant, high speed inter... more

one of the best hotels we have ever stayed at! more on Fodors

heart of a village on martha s vineyard island, this beautiful xixth century inn, surrounded by manicured gardens, is decorated in the best english style. more on Travelintelligence

$295

Got feedback?

The Shiverick Inn

AVERAGE RATING

5.0

1+ reviews

Yahoo! Travel

5

1+ reviews

non-smoking, cable television, refrigerator

Rooms are airy and bright, with high ceilings, lots of windows, eclectic american and english antiques and oriental rugs. more on Fodors

We just attended a wedding here. Our stay and celebration was incredible. We stayed at The Shiverick Inn. I love old Victorian inns that sparkle with crystal and silver, and of course exceptional... more on Bedandbreakfast

$270

Found a bug?

Harbor View Hotel

AVERAGE RATING

5.0

4+ reviews

Yahoo! Travel

5

4+ reviews

pool, room service, maid service, concierg... more

our best meal during our stay was dinner at the coach house more on Yahoo

centerpiece of this historic hotel is a gray-shingle, 1891 victorian building with wraparound veranda and a gazebo. more on Nytimes

$120

Is something missing?

Kelley House

AVERAGE RATING

4.0

3+ reviews

Yahoo! Travel

5

2+ reviews

pool, maid service, restaurant, high speed... more

rooms are spacious and comfortable and the homemade cookies and milk at 8 pm every night have us hooked more on Yahoo

The location of this hotel was great, but the room was pretty bad. It smelled damp,... more on Fodors

$150

Does this item belong in these results?

Clarion Carriage House Inn Martha*a Vineyard

AVERAGE RATING

4.0

7+ reviews

Orbitz	4	2+ reviews
Travelocity	3	4+ reviews
Yahoo! Travel	5	1+ reviews

maid service, restaurant, high speed inter... more

great value - clean rooms more on Travelocity

clarion marthas vineyard is located in the most elegant of the vineyards six towns, edgartown. more on Orbitz

$89

Have a suggestion?

The Harborside Inn

AVERAGE RATING

4.0

1+ reviews

Yahoo! Travel

4

1+ reviews

jacuzzi, spa, maid service, internet acces... more

is a swimming pool which my kids loved more on Yahoo

room was spotless and the service was great more on Yahoo

$225

Tell us what you think.

Shiretown Inn on Martha's Vineyard

AVERAGE RATING

5.0

1+ reviews

Yahoo! Travel

5

1+ reviews

room service, maid service, concierge desk... more

husband and I prefer to stay in the carriage houses as it is very quiet and relaxing more on Yahoo

Spent our Honeymoon here 23 years ago and we keep coming back. My husband and... more on Yahoo

$59

I love this! Here's why.

Point Way Inn

AVERAGE RATING

3.0

5+ reviews

Yahoo! Travel	2	2+ reviews
TripAdvisor	3	3+ reviews

maid service, non-smoking, cable televisio... more

staff was exceptionally friendly and accommodating, and made us feel as if we d been lifetime visitors more on Tripadvisor

I am sure it would follow the rest of the amenities - which are all lovely more on Yahoo

$230

How can we improve?

Colonial Inn on Marthas Vineyard

AVERAGE RATING

4.5

3+ reviews

Orbitz	3	1+ reviews
Yahoo! Travel	5	2+ reviews

spa, maid service, restaurant, health club... more

of edgartowns historic waterfront district is renownedfor its affordable luxury, exceptional harbor views andproximity to the choicest beaches ,. more on Hotels

we booked this hotel through expedia and got an excellent deal as it was out of season. more on Tripadvisor